100 Greatest Scenes Number 13 – Holding Hands

Views from the Sofa’s 100 Greatest Scenes is a list of the 100 greatest moments in the movies. This could be long introductions, moments of action or great dialogue between characters. The scenes are in no particular order and come from many different types of movies.

Over the three movies there are many different scenes from the Toy Story trilogy which could qualify for “greatest” but none evoke such a reaction as this one. After three movies, all of which as good as the last, Toy Story 3 seems to do what none could comprehend. Andy is growing up, the toys are “left behind,” seemingly forgotten and then came The Incinerator. For a minute and thirty seconds, which felt like a lifetime, the fans of the Toy Story characters were sure this was their final, proper end.

Greatest Scene Number 13: Toy Story 3 – Holding Hands

Toy Story 3 is as good as the first two movies and just as they do, it slowly builds to a great, action-packed climax. This time it is a chase through a landfill, which ends with the toys falling into an incinerator.

The scene starts with a cruel twist. It looks like cuddly villain Lotso could save them until he decides to walk away from the “kill switch” and let the toys burn in the furnace. Even then, as a viewer you can’t help but think they aren’t in real danger but then Pixar plays a very cruel trick.

Buzz starts the hand holding

The toys begin to fall down with the rest of the garbage, with Woody saving Rex from toppling into the flames. It is then that the real emotional gut-punch begins. The toys, led by Buzz giving his best, saddest eyes, grabbing Jessie’s hand with look of resolute acceptance.

This hand holding then begins to spread through the group, each toy grabbing hold of another. All of this down to the final connection, between the two toys who’s friendship has come the furthest, as Buzz holds his hand out for Woody. It is then that we get the wide shot, taking in all the toys as they slowly lower towards the fire.

The scene has no words and is sold on expression alone

This scene is a perfect example of what Pixar does best. Pixar knows emotion and their animation has moved on so far that this scene is done wordlessly. The fear, acceptance and reassurance is all told in the actions and more specifically, eyes of each character.

The real impact was the fact that the descent lasts longer than any audience is comfortable with. When you watch this for the first time you can’t help but feel that they could actually die. Almost everyone at some point, watching the toys accept their fate, thinks that this could be the most definite and cruelest ending to the trilogy.

For a second, just a second, you think they could really die

Of course the toys can’t die and Pixar actually save them in such a perfect way. It is especially satisfying because of who saves them, how they are saved and the fact that everyone will have forgotten about the little aliens and the garbage “claw.”

Overall, the reason the holding hands scene is so effective because it really sells the peril of the characters. The feeling of acceptance and the way they stand together, staring death in the face, will pull at anyone’s heart-strings. Of course they won’t die, even Pixar couldn’t end the trilogy that way, but for a second, just a second, you believe they might. That is the reason this scene is one of the greatest.

Sums up everything Toy Story is about

 Ps. The scene I found is in German (?) I think. I couldn’t find an English language one to embed.

Advertisements

5 comments

  1. Aw man – I was THIS CLOSE to bawling when they did this… and all seemed to just accept their fate. Even though it obviously couldn’t happen they kept this going just long enough to make the peril seem real.

    • That’s the key, it’s the way they wait just a little too long to rescue them. And don’t kid me with your “almost” bawling!

  2. What if they would have ended the movie this way? I secretly wish they did. Of course Pixar would have an issue with devastating children’s childhood, scarring them for life…but what an ending that would have been!

    • How would that work? Just the toys holding hands into the inevitable and then fade to black? Silent credits. It feels wrong just thinking about it.

    • NEVER TRUST ANYONE. DON’T RELY ON OTHERS.

      That would be awesome but completely scar a generation – and make grown men howl!

You've heard my opinion, let me know what you think...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s